I’ve been thinking a lot lately about our seemingly limitless capacity for self-loathing. Even the most braggadocious folks I meet usually reveal themselves pretty quickly. Beneath all the swagger and noise, you can almost always spot the hidden insecurity trying desperately to protect itself. Or, as Carl Jung would call it, the shadow parts of ourselves.
But what if those shadow parts are actually the very places that need the most compassion?
One of the quotes that has impacted me most in this arena comes from Brennan Manning in The Ragamuffin Gospel:
“To live by grace means to acknowledge my whole life story, the light side and the dark. In admitting my shadow side, I learn who I am and what God’s grace means.”
Then Manning follows it with a quote from Thomas Merton that has never quite let me go:
“A saint is not someone who is good but who experiences the goodness of God.”
I think about that a lot when I read the Beatitudes.
It intrigues me that the first major recorded teaching of Jesus in the Gospel of Matthew begins not with strength, certainty, moral performance, or spiritual achievement, but with this:
“Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the Kingdom of Heaven.”
Not the polished.
Not the impressive.
Not the people who already have themselves all fixed up.
The poor in spirit.
And if I’m being honest, I think we modern church folks are often deeply uncomfortable with those people.
Well… at least uncomfortable if they stay that way too long.
We love a dramatic testimony. We love repentance stories. We love the addict who comes forward crying at the altar. But after that? We start expecting rapid transformation. Pretty soon, if people are still struggling, still grieving, still mentally ill, still wrestling with addiction, shame, trauma, doubt, or the darker corners of themselves, folks begin quietly questioning the validity of their faith altogether.
And honestly? I think that breaks God’s heart.
I sometimes wonder if part of the problem is that many of us have never actually received mercy ourselves — at least not deeply.
Oh, we may believe in grace intellectually. We may preach it, sing about it, and post Bible verses about it online. But inwardly, many of us still live as though love must be earned through performance, improvement, certainty, or spiritual success.
And when people secretly despise the weak and wounded parts of themselves, they eventually become unable to tolerate those same things in others.
Maybe that’s part of what Jesus meant when He said:
“Blessed are the merciful, for they shall obtain mercy.”
What if mercy is not just something we give away, but something we must first allow ourselves to receive?
Because people who have truly encountered mercy tend to become merciful people.
And people who are still at war with themselves often end up weaponizing religion against everyone else.
No wonder the religious people of Jesus’ day accused Him of being a “friend of sinners.” Ironically, many churches now seem terrified of developing the same reputation. If a church becomes too welcoming to messy people, somebody inevitably accuses them of being soft on sin.
Which sounds suspiciously similar to what the Pharisees said about Jesus.
Now, I’m not pretending I’ve got all this figured out, because I absolutely do not. But it hurts my heart that the very people Jesus pronounced blessed are often the very people being quietly kept at arm’s length by religious gatekeepers.
Maybe that’s part of why this matters so much to me personally.
My therapy office is full of mask wearers. People carrying crushing burdens from trauma, addiction, anxiety, depression, OCD, grief, mental illness, loneliness, and shame. People who are already exhausted from trying to hold themselves together before they ever walk through the door. People who secretly fear that if others saw the full truth about them, they would no longer be welcome anywhere — including church.
Because the truth is, folks tend to have a pretty low tolerance for people who don’t get better in a hurry.
Especially in church culture.
But Jesus never said:
“Blessed are the poor in spirit because once they know Me, they’ll finally have it all together.”
I’ve been walking with Him for 21 years now, and I can promise you I still don’t have it all together. What I do believe is that my Heavenly Papa is extraordinarily patient, kind, and comfortable with my ongoing jacked-up-ed-ness.
And maybe that’s what grace actually is.
Maybe the Kingdom of Heaven was always meant for the misfits, the exhausted, the addicted, the ashamed, the doubters, the wounded, the mentally ill, the spiritually burned out, and the ones still carrying around more shadow than they know what to do with.
In other words, people like us.
Welcome to the party.
No responses yet